With the popularity of TMZ, ET, and various other news or tabloid outlets, audiences spend more time talking about the controversial actor rather than talking about the controversial actor’s body of work. Information is at our finger tips each time we wish to hear about the latest rehab stint or run in with the law of our favorite celebrities. Sometimes we cheer them on during their long road to recover. Other times we vilify them and point to what could have been. Our minds consider what we could have done with their wasted opportunities. Lately, things have taken a different turn. The troubled actor meets with the troubled character to create a perfect storm. The actors are able to pull from their own experience to add depth to the sometimes shallow characters they portray. On top of all this, we add our own information about the actor onto the role, giving us multiple layers that may not have been there before.
If there is an actor that best suits this description it is Robert Downey Jr. Once considered a rising star in the late 80’s, his run-in’s with the law left most people itching for the next news reel instead of itching for the next movie reel. His early roles in Weird Science and The Pickup Artist showed that he was easy to watch and easily changed. His role as Charlie Chaplin inĀ Chaplin marked the height of his early success. He was nominated for an Oscar in 1993. Things quickly headed south as drugs and legal battles kept him from being as useful to the business as he could be. After hitting rock bottom, he needed to build his career back up from the shambles that it had become.
It wasn’t until Jon Favreau took a chance on an unproven draw like Downey that things turned around completely. Robert had never been a blockbuster actor. While critical success had found him easily, money making features were not in his resume. Luckily, Favreau saw the link between his title comic book character and the troubled actor. Tony Stark is a drunk egomaniac who, while filled with good intentions, wants the world to revolve around him. It would be hard to argue that Robert Downey Jr. didn’t share that description in the real world. Thus his performance came naturally. Sometimes so naturally that the comic book itself was rewritten on camera. A Marvel character that had been an unproven commodity on the big screen quickly became the its hottest property. Tony Stark is Robert Downey Jr. However, there is an argument to be made that Downey’s controversial past is what made it possible for his portrayal of Tony Stark to be life-like.
Vincent Gallo, an artist also known for creating controversy, is most known for his over the top personality. While few have seen The Brown Bunny most know about it’s controversial material and the wars that ensued because of it. The best way to describe Vincent Gallo is to call him an enigma. He has dabbled in music, paint, film, acting, modeling and just about any other form of art you can think of. His most memorable work has to be his role as an actor/director in Buffalo 66. What you watched on the screen was never a character but Gallo himself. The same man that wished colon cancer on Roger Ebert and talked wildly against selling your soul to the business he sold his own to several times. While Gallo the person has never been the most likable character, it has enabled him to flesh out the visions of similarly unlikable characters on screen. In Francis Coppola’s latest film Tetro Gallo plays an anger filled writer who constantly looks for separation from the work he’s done. While many men could have provided a more than adequate performance, Gallo adds his own unique perspective on a character that he seemed destined to play. Tetro the character is loud, insulting, deranged, and sometimes manic. All traits that can easily be traced back to Gallo himself.
Does controversy make the controversial actor or does the controversial actor make the controversial role? We’ve seen how success has poisoned even the most talented actors and we’ve also seen what the few that survive have become. Life experience is at a premium in entertainment. It can be harnessed but never duplicated. All it takes a few glimpses at the wooden performances filling current theater screens to wonder if life experience truly does make the difference.